Philosopher · Modern
Swami Vivekananda
1863–1902 · Neo-Vedanta: practical Advaita, the harmony of religions, service as worship
The monk who carried Vedanta to the Parliament of Religions at Chicago in 1893 and founded the Ramakrishna Mission; Catholic monks in India from Monchanin to Abhishiktananda spent their lives answering the Advaita he made modern.
Narendranath Datta, a Calcutta graduate and disciple of the ecstatic Ramakrishna, became Swami Vivekananda and taught in “Raja Yoga,” “Jnana Yoga,” “Karma Yoga” and “Bhakti Yoga” that each soul is potentially divine, that religion is the realization of that divinity by one of four paths, and that the dualist, qualified non-dualist and non-dualist schools are stages on one ascent whose summit is Shankara's Advaita. Religion must be verified by experience as science is by experiment, scriptures are maps and not the country, and images and rituals are lower steps that are not to be despised. He held that it is a sin to call a man a sinner, that all religions are true and converge, that service of the poor is service of God (daridra narayana), and that India's mission to the world is spiritual while her task at home is strength, education and the lifting of the masses; he called himself a socialist for want of anything better and founded the Mission in 1897 to join contemplation with relief.
Why he matters: He created the Hinduism most Westerners know, in which all religions are paths to one summit, and the Catholic reply to that claim, from Monchanin's Shantivanam to Abhishiktananda's “Saccidananda” and Dominus Iesus, was written with him in view; his insistence that religion be tested by experience and issue in service is a challenge Catholic India took up in its own ashrams. Nostra Aetate's praise of Hindu “searching philosophical inquiry” and its warning against indifferentism are both addressed to his heirs.
Where to be careful
The potential divinity of every soul and the ascent to non-duality deny the real distinction of Creator and creature taught at Lateran IV and Vatican I, the harmony of religions is the indifferentism of Mirari Vos and Dominus Iesus 22, and the denial of sin empties the need for redemption; rebirth and a final absorption contradict the resurrection. Common ground: the dignity of the human person, the service of the poor as service of God, the demand that religion be lived and not merely assented to, and the respect for celibacy and renunciation.
Reading
-
Raja YogaSwami Vivekananda · His New York lectures on meditation with a translation of Patanjali's sutras; the practical Vedanta as he taught it to Westerners.
-
Vivekananda: A BiographySwami Nikhilananda · The standard life from within the Ramakrishna Order, with the Chicago addresses.
-
Saccidananda: A Christian Approach to Advaitic ExperienceAbhishiktananda (Henri Le Saux) · A Benedictine who lived the Advaita experience and tried to hold it within the Trinity; the deepest Catholic reply to the Vedanta he preached.
Documented positions
Where this thinker stands on each question the test asks.