All thinkers

Philosopher · Antiquity

Mencius (Mengzi)

c. 372–289 BC · Confucianism; the idealist wing

Pre-Christian Confucian

The second sage of Confucianism; Ricci and the Jesuit mission built their case for the natural knowledge of God and the natural law on his reading of human nature, and Nostra Aetate 2 commends what is true and holy in the Chinese traditions.

Mencius taught that human nature is good: every person is born with four “sprouts,” compassion, shame, deference and the sense of right and wrong, which grow into benevolence, righteousness, propriety and wisdom if nourished and die if neglected, as the trees of Ox Mountain die when the axe comes every day. The sage is therefore not a different kind of man but one who has extended what every heart already has, and the child about to fall into the well shows that no one lacks the heart that cannot bear the suffering of others. In politics he told kings that the people are the most important element and the ruler the least, that a ruler who abandons benevolence is a “mere fellow” whom Heaven's mandate has left, and that government begins with securing the people's livelihood; he fought the Mohist doctrine of impartial care as a denial of the father and Yang Zhu's egoism as a denial of the ruler.

Why he matters: He is the Confucian witness to the law written on the heart (Romans 2:14–15), and Matteo Ricci and the Jesuits read him so, siding with him against Xunzi on the goodness of nature in The True Meaning of the Lord of Heaven; the 1939 decree permitting the Confucian rites rested in part on this reading. Catholic scholars from Julia Ching to the Jesuit sinologists have found in his “four sprouts” the nearest Chinese parallel to synderesis.

Where to be careful

Heaven is for him a moral order rather than a personal Creator, there is no inherited fault and no need of grace, and the goodness of nature is the whole story in a way the Church, which teaches original sin and a nature wounded but good (Trent, Session 5; CCC 405), cannot accept. His doctrine of a moral sense common to all, of graded love rooted in the family, and of a ruler bound by Heaven and answerable for the people's welfare is close to Catholic social teaching.

Reading

  • Mencius
    Mencius (trans. D. C. Lau) · The standard English version, with Lau's essays on the argument for the goodness of nature.
  • Mengzi: With Selections from Traditional Commentaries
    Mencius (trans. Bryan W. Van Norden) · A translation that lets Zhu Xi and other commentators speak alongside the text.
  • Confucianism and Christianity: A Comparative Study
    Julia Ching · A Catholic sinologist sets Mencius's heart-mind and the Confucian Heaven beside the Christian doctrine of conscience and God.

Documented positions

Where this thinker stands on each dispute the test covers.

Settled teaching Its center Open question Beyond teaching, not condemned Condemned error
I

God and Being · What is, and whence it is.

Can reason know that God exists? Natural theology
Fideism or agnosticism Natural theology
How is God related to the world? Creation from nothing
Pantheism or emanation Creation from nothing
Is the world governed by purpose? Providence and final causes
Chance and mechanism Providence and final causes
Do natures and essences really exist? Realism
Nominalism Realism
How should we speak of God? Between
Apophatic (negative) way Cataphatic (analogical) way
II

Faith, Reason and Truth · How we know, and whom we trust.

Where does knowledge begin? Illumination and innate ideas
Senses and abstraction Illumination and innate ideas
Is truth objective? Objective truth
Relativism and pragmatism Objective truth
Who interprets revelation? Living Tradition and Magisterium
Private judgment Living Tradition and Magisterium
III

The Human Person · Soul, body, freedom and the Fall.

Is there a spiritual soul? Immortal spiritual soul
Mind is brain Immortal spiritual soul
Is the body really you? Body–soul unity
Dualism Body–soul unity
Are you free? Free will
Determinism Free will
How fallen is human nature? Basically good
Totally depraved Basically good
The body and its desires Desire as its own law
Contempt for the flesh Desire as its own law
Person and community Collectivism
Individualism Collectivism
Marriage, sex and the body's meaning Given by nature and grace
Given by nature and grace Defined by consent and identity
What is suffering for? A share in the Cross
An evil to be relieved A share in the Cross
IV

The Moral Life · Law, virtue, conscience and the good.

Is morality objective and knowable? Natural law
Relativism Natural law
Why is the good good? Eternal law (intellectualism)
Divine command (voluntarism) Eternal law (intellectualism)
Are some acts always wrong? Intrinsically evil acts
Consequentialism Intrinsically evil acts
Rules or character? Morality of virtue and beatitude
Morality of obligation Morality of virtue and beatitude
What is conscience? Conscience bound to truth
Autonomous conscience Conscience bound to truth
In doubtful cases Laxism
Rigorism Laxism
What is happiness? Earthly flourishing
Earthly flourishing Beatitude in God
VI

Church and Society · Authority, the state, wealth and the nation.

Church and state Social kingship of Christ
Laicism Social kingship of Christ
The economic order Socialism
Socialism Laissez-faire capitalism
Where does authority come from? Authority from God
Social contract Authority from God
Reform or tradition? Guided by tradition
Remake by reason Guided by tradition
The nation and the Church Nation or race first
Nation or race first Nation does not matter
Which form of government best suits a Christian people? Monarchy and hierarchy
Monarchy and hierarchy Democracy and participation
May a Christian take up the sword? Between
Never: the way of the Cross is nonviolence Yes: war can be just and sometimes a duty
VII

Worship, Prayer and the Two Lungs · Liturgy, icons, the Spirit, and the See of Peter.

Liturgical development Receive and develop organically
Reconstruct and innovate Receive and develop organically
Contemplation or action? Action: the apostolate and the works of mercy
Action: the apostolate and the works of mercy Contemplation: the one thing needful

A profile of your philosophical and theological leanings, measured against the settled teaching of the Catholic Church, East and West. It is a tool for examination and reading, not an instrument of judgment.

Ad maiorem Dei gloriam.