Writer · Modern
Fyodor Dostoevsky
1821–1881 · Orthodox Christian personalism (in fiction)
A devout Russian Orthodox layman whose faith passed, as he said, “through the crucible of doubt.”
Dostoevsky's novels dramatize the great modern questions: freedom and its abuse (Notes from Underground), the murderer's conscience (Crime and Punishment), the Christ-like fool (The Idiot), revolutionary nihilism (Demons) and the choice between the Grand Inquisitor and Christ (The Brothers Karamazov). Through the elder Zosima he taught active love, responsibility of each for all, and the resurrection of the whole person.
Why he matters: De Lubac's Drama of Atheist Humanism ends with him as the prophet who answers Nietzsche; Guardini, Balthasar, Benedict XVI and Pope Francis all read him; “beauty will save the world” and “if there is no God, everything is permitted” have become Catholic commonplaces.
Where to be careful
He is outside Catholic communion though treasured by Eastern Catholics; the Grand Inquisitor and Prince Myshkin voice a fierce anti-Catholic polemic, his Russian messianism and pan-Slavism tend toward the nationalism the Church condemns, and his Diary contains antisemitic passages; he holds the Orthodox positions on the Filioque and the papacy that Florence and Vatican I define otherwise.
Reading
-
The Brothers KaramazovFyodor Dostoevsky · The Grand Inquisitor and the Zosima chapters especially.
-
Notes from UndergroundFyodor Dostoevsky · Freedom against the crystal palace of rationalism.
-
The Drama of Atheist Humanism (Part III)Henri de Lubac, SJ · Dostoevsky as prophet; the Catholic reading.
Documented positions
Where this thinker stands on each question the test asks.